DESD PSS: PHER WG - FHIR Resources
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Return to Domain Experts Electronic Voting Summaries
Please vote on the PSS for the PHER WG. Enter your name and WG along with your vote. 1 vote per WG. Poll open until June 18, 2014.
Link to PSS: PHER PSS FHIR Resources
Link to Updated PSS: Updated PSS
Link to Doodle Poll: Doodle Poll Link
Summary
- Number of participants: 13
- Most popular option: Affirmative
- Votes in favor: 13
- Comments: 6
- Non-participating work groups counted as abstaining solely for the purpose of counting quorum:
Vote
| ' | Affirmative | Negative (with comments) | Abstain |
| John Walsh (Anesthesia) | OK | ||
| Jim McClay (ECWG) | OK | ||
| John Kiser (RCRIM) | OK | ||
| Floyd Eisenberg (CQI) | OK | ||
| John Rhoads (HCD/DEV) | OK | ||
| Elaine Ayres (Patient Care) | OK | ||
| Craig Gabron (AWG) | OK | ||
| Joginder Madra (PHER) | OK | ||
| Melva Peters (Pharmacy) | OK | ||
| Edward Helton BRIDG | OK | ||
| Michael Padula (Child Health) | OK | ||
| Dianne Reeves | OK | ||
| Count | 12 | 0 | 0 |
Comments
| Melva Peters Friday, June 13,2014 | The PHER FHIR PSS has been updated to reflect that the work is related to updates to existing FHIR resources and possible creation of profiles/extensions. http://gforge.hl7.org/gf/project/desd/scmsvn/?action=browse&path=%2Ftrunk%2FDocuments%2FProjectScopeStatements%2F2014%2FHL7%2520FHIR%2520Project%2520Scope%2520Statement%2520v2013.1_FHIR_Immunization_2014June.doc&sortby=date&view=log |
| Melva Peters Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | A PSS is required for any work that you are doing as a WG. Your initial PSS for FHIR resources likely only included the work for the initial DSTU. Any subsequent work will need a new PSS. |
| Joginder Madra Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | This PSS was created after our FHIR joint session in Phoenix. Our understanding of the DSTU 2 process: http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=FHIR_Ballot_Prep. Additionally, as we believe this represents an additional set of activities - primarily updates to resources based on DSTU comments to date as well as new quality requirements for DSTU 2 - we felt a new PSS was warranted. |
| Elaine Ayres Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | I was not aware that we needed PSS statements for moving resources into the DSTU ballot. If that is so, then we need a larger discussion about FHIR processes. The FHIR group told us that if a resource is used by the community, then they would move it forward. What is the purpose of designating specific resources and should we all be moving in this direction? Thanks |
| Joginder Madra Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | Elaine, this PSS is for moving the existing resources into the second DSTU ballot |
| Elaine Ayres Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | This PSS is for two FHIR resources that already exist - Immunization and Immunization Recommnedation. Does PHER intend this as a profile PSS, or is this a maintenance PSS for these two existing resources. If these are two new distinct resources, the difference from the current resources needs to be made clear. |
Work Group Health and PBS Metrics Review
- Work Group Health: Green
- PBS Metrics: Red
