DESD: PSS HL7 V3 Birth Fetal Death Reporting CDA from PHER
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Return to Domain Experts Electronic Voting Summaries
Please vote on the PSS for the PHER WG. Enter your name and WG along with your vote. 1 vote per WG. Poll open until 2/27/2012 unless quorum is reached earlier. Link to Document:
PSS HL7 V3 Birth Fetal Death Reporting CDA
- Summary - Passed (6/0/2/2)
- Number of participants: 8
- Most popular option: Affirmative
- Votes in favor: 6
- Comments: 2
- Non-participating work groups counted as abstaining solely for the purpose of counting quorum: 0
| Co-Chairs | Affirmative | Negative | Abstain |
| Joy Kuhl (child health) | OK | ||
| John Roberts (PHER) | OK | ||
| edward helton-RCRIM | OK | ||
| Jim McKinley (AWG) | OK | ||
| Hugh Glover (Pharmacy) | OK | ||
| Mollie Ullman-Cullere (CG) | OK | ||
| Suzanne Gonzales-Webb (CBCC) | OK | ||
| Mead Walker (PS WG) | OK | ||
| Count | 6 | 0 | 2 |
NOTE: edward helton-RCRIM failed to select a voting option and therefore was counted as Abstain.
Comments
| Name | Date | Time | Comment |
| Suzanne Gonzales-Webb | Wednesday, February 8, 2012 | 5:16:31 AM GMT-12:00 | Forgive me for being naive, but why are there two separate death reporting CDAs. Is Fetal death vs ‘other’ death that different in the reporting? |
| Mollie Ullman-Cullere | Sunday, February 12, 2012 | 6:21:16 AM GMT-12:00 | This information is valuable. Will the work focus on transmission or tackle coding as well? (I hope coding is included.) |
The following response to the comment from Suzanne Gonzales-Webb was provided via e-mail by John Roberts and Michelle Williamson:
From: John A. Roberts [John.A.Roberts@tn.gov] Sent: Tuesday, February 14, 2012 8:29 AM To: Williamson, Michelle (CDC/OSELS/NCHS); edward.tripp@estripp.com Subject: RE: V3 CDA Birth and Fetal Death Reporting IG Ballot Comments Michelle, This should address the comment. I'll ask Ed Tripp to add the comment to the poll, or better, eitehr forward this to Suzanne. Ed, Could we get the two paragraphs set off by asterisks below added to the poll as a comment? Also, if you have an email address for Suzanne Gonzales-Webb would you please forward this to her? (or is this automatic with the poll comment?) john John Roberts Health Systems Architect Tennessee Department of Health Phone 615-741-3702 Email john.a.roberts@tn.gov and Co-Chair, Public Health and Emergency Response Work Group, Health Level 7 International (HL7) From: Williamson, Michelle (CDC/OSELS/NCHS) [zup9@cdc.gov] Sent: Monday, February 13, 2012 1:21 PM To: John A. Roberts Subject: RE: V3 CDA Birth and Fetal Death Reporting IG Ballot Comments Hi John, Thanks so much for your attempt to contact me regarding the DESD response to the PSS for VR CDA IGs. I see that the vote passed without a response; however, I thought you may still want to provide feedback in case this comes up again with the TSC. I would propose the following response to Suzanne Gonzales-Webb or others who want clarification: ***** Information needed to officially record a fetal death in the 57 U.S. vital records jurisdictions is defined by the U.S. Standard Report of Fetal Death. The project to develop a CDA IG for Birth and Fetal Death Reporting is based on the requirements for the U.S. Standard Certificate of Live Birth and the U.S. Standard Report of Fetal Death. Information needed to officially record a death in the 57 U.S. vital records jurisdictions is defined by the U.S. Standard Certificate of Death. The project to develop a CDA IG for Death Reporting is based on these reporting requirements that are different from those specified for fetal death reporting. ***** John, Does this address the comment in your opinion or is more needed? Michelle Michelle Williamson CDC/NCHS/CPHDSS Ph: 301-458-4618 Em: mwilliamson@cdc.gov
