EMS Constrained Information Model Project Scope

Return to Domain Experts Electronic Voting Summaries

Please vote on the project scope for the Clinical Interoperability Council Emergency Medical Services Constrained Information Model & Interoperability Specifications. Enter your name and Work Group along with your vote. Only one vote per Work Group please. Any comments added through the poll should also be distributed to the DESD list server. Link to Document: Clinical Interoperability Council Emergency Medical Services Constrained Information Model Project Scope

• Summary - Passed (8/1/1/4)
  • Number of participants: 10
  • Most popular option: Affirmative
  • Votes in favor: 8
  • Comments: 2
  • Non-participating work groups counted as abstaining solely for the purpose of counting quorum: 5

Comments

• Ed Tripp July 7, 2010 10:51 AM CDT

I have amended the vote on the wiki to move Jim McClay's vote from Negative to Affirmative.

• Jim McClay July 6, 2010 5:52 PM CDT

Ed, I’ve been able to access the document and agree to withdraw my negative vote. Thanks,

James McClay, MD, FACEP

• Jim McClay June 24, 2010 10:58:40 AM CDT

We are unable to open the gforge document as it seems to be password protected. Therefore Emergency Care votes Negative until the documents are made available to the general HL7 membership and easily found.

• Melvin Reynolds (DEV) June 22, 2010 9:54:24 AM CDT

Sorry, DEV always being the bad boys! This proposal states that it addresses a clear USA requirement, but is scoped as UniversalRealm . It would be appropriate either to amend the Realm to USA, or provide evidence of universal requirements being considered. On the basis of either change DEV would amend its vote to 'approve'.

Votes

'	Affirmative	Negative	Abstain
Edward Tripp (RCRIM)	OK
Helmut Koenig (II)	OK
Melvin Reynolds (DEV)		OK
Rita Altamore (PHER)	OK
Rita Altamore (PHER)	OK
Jim McClay (ECWG	OK
Mead Walker (Patient Safety)	OK
Anita Walden (CIC)	OK
richard thoreson (CBCC)	OK
Alan Nicol (GAS)			OK
Count	8	1	1