DESD PSS: PHER WG - FHIR Resources
Return to Domain Experts Electronic Voting Summaries
Please vote on the PSS for the PHER WG. Enter your name and WG along with your vote. 1 vote per WG. Poll open until June 18, 2014.
Link to PSS: PHER PSS FHIR Resources
Link to Updated PSS: Updated PSS
Link to Doodle Poll: Doodle Poll Link
Summary
- Number of participants: 13
- Most popular option: Affirmative
- Votes in favor: 13
- Comments: 6
- Non-participating work groups counted as abstaining solely for the purpose of counting quorum:
Vote
| ' | Affirmative | Negative (with comments) | Abstain |
| John Walsh (Anesthesia) | OK | ||
| Jim McClay (ECWG) | OK | ||
| John Kiser (RCRIM) | OK | ||
| Floyd Eisenberg (CQI) | OK | ||
| John Rhoads (HCD/DEV) | OK | ||
| Elaine Ayres (Patient Care) | OK | ||
| Craig Gabron (AWG) | OK | ||
| Joginder Madra (PHER) | OK | ||
| Melva Peters (Pharmacy) | OK | ||
| Edward Helton BRIDG | OK | ||
| Michael Padula (Child Health) | OK | ||
| Dianne Reeves | OK | ||
| Count | 12 | 0 | 0 |
Comments
| Melva Peters Friday, June 13,2014 | The PHER FHIR PSS has been updated to reflect that the work is related to updates to existing FHIR resources and possible creation of profiles/extensions. http://gforge.hl7.org/gf/project/desd/scmsvn/?action=browse&path=%2Ftrunk%2FDocuments%2FProjectScopeStatements%2F2014%2FHL7%2520FHIR%2520Project%2520Scope%2520Statement%2520v2013.1_FHIR_Immunization_2014June.doc&sortby=date&view=log |
| Melva Peters Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | A PSS is required for any work that you are doing as a WG. Your initial PSS for FHIR resources likely only included the work for the initial DSTU. Any subsequent work will need a new PSS. |
| Joginder Madra Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | This PSS was created after our FHIR joint session in Phoenix. Our understanding of the DSTU 2 process: http://wiki.hl7.org/index.php?title=FHIR_Ballot_Prep. Additionally, as we believe this represents an additional set of activities - primarily updates to resources based on DSTU comments to date as well as new quality requirements for DSTU 2 - we felt a new PSS was warranted. |
| Elaine Ayres Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | I was not aware that we needed PSS statements for moving resources into the DSTU ballot. If that is so, then we need a larger discussion about FHIR processes. The FHIR group told us that if a resource is used by the community, then they would move it forward. What is the purpose of designating specific resources and should we all be moving in this direction? Thanks |
| Joginder Madra Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | Elaine, this PSS is for moving the existing resources into the second DSTU ballot |
| Elaine Ayres Wednesday, May 28, 2014 | This PSS is for two FHIR resources that already exist - Immunization and Immunization Recommnedation. Does PHER intend this as a profile PSS, or is this a maintenance PSS for these two existing resources. If these are two new distinct resources, the difference from the current resources needs to be made clear. |
Work Group Health and PBS Metrics Review
- Work Group Health: Green
- PBS Metrics: Red
